Who’s right? Honestly, they all are. Calling someone mom and dad is a personal choice. It is up to you and your spouse to decide whether you want to call your in-laws mom and dad. Frankly, no one would argue that people earn the title of parent and don’t just get it bestowed upon them, even if it seems that way sometimes.
In the time leading up to the wedding and the first year of marriage, you will be establishing a deeper connection with your spouse and his or her family. That will be the period in which you decide how to refer to your in-laws and what kind of relationship you’ll have. Ideally, you’ll connect with one another based on your shared love of your spouse. Perhaps, this shared love will even keep your temper from flaring when you disagree with one another and will drive you to work out any differences you might have.
As you spend more time with your spouse’s family, you will – you should hope – become closer. In that case, you may feel compelled to call your in-laws mom and dad. Letting the words come out naturally and fluidly in conversation would be a great way to establish the tradition of calling them mom and dad. And it will show that they earned the title, which should cause respect to grow among you.
Some in-laws might expect for you to start calling them mom and dad either after the engagement or after the wedding. If this is the case, your spouse should tell you about his or her parents’ expectations. Then, you have to honestly express what you think about the idea of calling your in-laws mom and dad. If you’re for it, then the conversation will be short.
If you’re against it, you have to remain calm and gently let your spouse know why you don’t want to call your in-laws mom and dad. I say gently because this could hurt the feelings of your spouse or put him or her in an awkward position with the folks. Be sympathetic and, if your reason is that you don’t get along with your in-laws or don’t like them very much, refrain from saying anything bad about them. Remember, these are the people who raised your spouse, and for that they deserve your respect and gratitude, if not the title of mom and dad. That said, you should not feel forced to call someone mom and dad if you don’t feel it’s the right thing to do. You want to create a relationship that works both ways and satisfies your in-laws and you.
You might find that, at first, you don’t want to call your in-laws mom and dad, but you change your mind down the line. Perhaps, after you have kids and you see the bond your in-laws share with your children, you’ll feel like honoring them with the title of mom and dad. Some people need that kind of time to adjust to their new married life and this new relationship they have with another family. That’s perfectly natural.
Other people never feel comfortable calling their in-laws mom and dad, and that is perfectly all right, too. If you decide not to call your in-laws mom and dad, you must share your decision with your spouse. Realize that you can refrain from calling your spouse’s parents mom and dad, even if he or she wants to call your parents mom and dad. Guilt should not be part of this decision. If your spouse or your in-laws are making you feel guilty about the decision, you should stick to your guns, rationally explain your reasons, and affirm your love for the family and devotion to your spouse and leave it at that. Whatever agreement you and your spouse work out is okay, as long as you both actually agree with the decision and do your best to keep peace with your extended family.
Those who do not call their in-laws mom or dad should refer to them either as Mr. and Mrs. Smith or Jane and John. You can determine whether last names or first names are best based on the type of relationship you share, how well you know each other, and sometimes how far away you live from one another. Formal couples, who live far away from their kids and have only met their child’s spouse a few times before the wedding, might prefer being called by their last names, whereas a casual couple whose kids live down the block with their spouses might want you to call them by their first name or even a nickname. Follow their cues and your heart, and you’ll make the right decision for you and your new family.